Puerto Rico
Publisher: Alea/Ravensburger
Author: Andreas Seyfarth
Tester: Aaron Haag, Hans R. Frey
Game Tested: German release, 2002
Scenario: Puerto Rico – the small island of the West Indies is the setting for this fight for wealth and honor of 3 to 5 players. By building plantations and production plants as well as important support facilities, and by exporting goods, players try to accumulate victory points. Players start with just one little corn field and no buildings, and face the task of setting up a prosperous production chain of goods ready for export or local sale in order to generate the money necessary for further expansion.
The Game: Each player is given his own placemat depicting the town of San Juan with 12 available spaces for buildings and a settlement area with room for up to 12 plantations. A separate board represents the „Bank“ for doubloons, the currency of the game, and holds the available buildings. Buildings come in two flavors: there are plants to produce goods from crop (like e.g. the sugar mill) and there are buildings that provide the player with special abilities (like e.g. a market place which allows the player to sell goods already present in the trading house).
The motor of the game are the „character cards“ or „roles“ which provide the players with a means to control the sequence of phases in which the game is played. Beginning with the start player (represented by „Governor“ card) each player selects a character. Different to other games with a number of roles all players perform the action associated with the selected character. The benefit for the selecting player (besides first choice when performing the action) is the right to make use of a special „privilege“ each character provides. Basically, this mechanism makes the players determine the sequence of actions performed in a round and is of great tactical importance. Also, there are 3 more character cards in play than there are players, making it possible to avoid certain actions in a particular round at all. Once all players have selected their character and hence all have played the actions of all characters selected the round ends and the Govenor is handed to the next player not before a doubloon each is placed on the 3 character cards that have not been selected in this round (making them more attractive in the next round).
The actions and privileges of the character cards are:
-
- Settler
Each player selects a plantation to be placed on his island. Privilege: the player may choose to place a quarry instead.
- Mayor
Players receive colonists from the colonist ship. All colonists on the island may be redistributed. Privilege: the mayor receives one extra colonist from stock.
- Builder
Players may build one of the available buildings by paying the appropiate cost in doubloons. Privilege: the builder pays one doubloon less.
- Craftsman
Players receive goods according to their production chains. Privilege: the craftsman receives an extra token of one of the goods produced.
- Trader
Players may sell one goods token to the trading house. Privilege: the trader receives one extra doubloon for his token.
- Captain
Players must place goods on available ships and receive a victory point chip for each goods token placed. Privilege: the captain receives one extra victory point.
- Prospector
No action. Privilege: the prospector takes one doubloon from the bank.
At the start of the game the settler and the builder are the most useful characters because they are required to build plantations and buildings – both being vital for successful production chains. Plantations come in 5 different types: indigo, sugar, corn, tobacco and coffee, in order of abundance. 
With the exception of corn all other crops require a processing plant in order to generates goods for sale or shipment. Some plants come in two different sizes with the smaller size being available at a lower price. A production chain requires that each plantation used for production as well as the production plant itself is occupied by colonists.
While plantations come for free in the Settler phase building need to be paid for and money (doubloons) is very scarce in this game. Players start the game with between 2 to 4 doubloons depending on the number of players and buildings cost between 1 and 10 doubloons to construct. One way out of this shortage of money is to place quarries instead of plantations, as each quarry occupied by a colonist lowers the building price by one doubloon in the Builder phase.
There are, of course, ways to generate money. The first way is to sell goods to the trading house. Each commodity may only be present once in the house and the storage capacity is small as well (4 tokens). If a good can be sold in the Trader phase the money a player receives depends on the commodity sold, ranging from zero(!) doubloons for corn to four doubloons for coffee. The second way to receive money is by selecting character cards with doubloons on them. Often at the beginning of a round some cards have two doubloons on them making them rather attractive to take. Sometimes even a prospector has this two doubloons bonus because that role has not been chosen since two rounds making it an attractive 3 doubloons deal this round. Anyway, generating money is certainly not an easy task.
Another very scarce resource of the game are the colonists. No plantation, quarry or building operates or provides special benefits if not occupied by one or more colonists. As explained before, this is most important in producrion chains. Colonists arrive on the colonist ship in a varying number depending on the number of players and the number of open positions in buildings. In the Mayor’s phase all colonists are distributed amongst the players in sequence and the players may place these colonists on any position they have vacant at the time (plus they may redistribute all colonists on their island). Most of the time a player will receive only 1 colonist per round so getting one’s plantations and buildings fully operational takes time.
The decisive element, however, are victory points. On the one hand they are generated in the captain’s phase by placing goods on available ships. As there are only three ships available, each ship has a limited capacity, and each ship may only carry one commodity at a time, often some goods cannot be placed at all. This can pose a serious problem as goods must be placed on a ship if possible but goods not placed due to the unavailability of a ship must either be placed in an operational storage building or are lost – a situation to avoid at all cost.
At the end of the game victory points are also credited for each building a player has, irrespective of whether it is occupied by a colonist or not. The four „large“ buildings (if occupied !) generate extra victory points (the fortress for example provides 1 extra victory point for every 3 colonists on the players board).The game end is variable: it occurs at the end of the round where either an insufficient amount of colonists is available to fully stock the colonist ship or at least one player has buildings on each of his 12 town fields or when all victory point chips have been distributed.
Playing Time: The game can be explained in 15 minutes and played in about 2 hours.
Similar Games: Princes of Florence
Westpark Gamer’s Opinion: Like many good games Puerto Rico has a strong timing and resource management (i.e. tactical) component combined with several strategic options. It has actually been quite a while that we have seen a new game which leaves such a wide scope for different strategies and at the same time provides the permanent challenges of tactical decisions. Many times during a game one is faced with a situation that the obvious best move for oneself has just been destroyed by another player by picking the character card one wanted to select, too. Therefore, most of the time you are forced to devise a „plan B“ and sometime even „plan C“ which you can use as alternatives. This sounds complicated and hard to grasp but we found that this comes quite naturally when getting familiar with the game while it does no harm if the players are not yet familiar with all strategic options.
Overall, the number of strategic variants seem to be quite high. Until now we have not yet found a sure winning strategy though and in fact we believe that there is none which will work all the time – again a sign of a good game. A Player needs to constantly be watching the moves of the others in order to adjust his or her strategy accordingly and at the same time prevent the other players to build up „winning combinations“. For example, allowing a player to build lots of corn fields, a hospice and a shipyard most likely means victory for that player. Similar situations arise if a player is allowed to build more than one large building generating extra VPs at the end of the game. This aspect of the game is what makes it rather complex because depriving other players of certain building does not necessarily match with your own strategy. Sometimes this means that one has to play the Captain just to create e.g. a „coffee“ ship with one coffee in order to prevent another player to get VPs for all his corns. Or you may already have sufficient doubloons but are faced with a situation where you need to take a prospector with 2 extra doubloons just to prevent someone else to get enough money for that winning shipyard. Throughout the game players are in the type of dilemma situation where they would like to do several things at once but are only allowed to take one action – another indication of a good game.
Player interactions are quite low though and are mainly limited to cautious hints to other players or „I wanted to take that role, too“ type sighs. This can lead to a rather „quite“ gaming session but due to the fact that everybody feels involved all of the time we never found this to be a problem.
Some words about strategies: in our games the number of VPs required for winning the game varied between 28 and 43 – a rather wide spread although the distance between first and last position in most cases was rather small (less than 10 points). This can be attributed to the different strategies we followed as our experience grew. From what we have learnt so far it seems to be wise to keep a good balance between VPs generated by production and those generated by the buildings (a 50:50 share seems okay). And unless you are playing with newcomers to the game it is a good idea to try and produce at least 3 different types of goods. Clever building selection also plays a major role. Keep an eye on the „hospice“ and if possible try to grab one of the two available. We found this building to be one of the most powerful of the game and one has to prevent other players from building „power combinations“ with it (like „hospice“/“builder’s hut“ or „hospice“/“shipyard“).
Hans‘ strategy hints: A word of caution in advance: I have never won in this game yet, though I haven’t lost very badly, either. What I like best in this game, is that the actions of all players interact and create a different feel each time. What works one day, need not work another. This said, let me propose a few ideas:
Life is short: The last round inevitably comes too early for you. Running down the game clock can be your best strategy, or it can ruin your best plan. Normally, colonists run out fastest, but watch out for the other two types of game ending. Don’t do anything in the endgame which bears fruit too late!
Build big: Normally, you will (at game end) need one of the X-large buildings for extra victory points. Get two, and you’re top dog. It is essential to know where the money is to come from in that final builder phase. And remember, you need to shuffle a colonist on it later!
Take the money and run: Sometimes, the best way to make money is by selecting a not-so-hot character with many doubloons on it – but don’t do that too often (see hint #1).
Play along: In most rounds, you’re not te governor, and if you are: good luck, as you’ll be the last to pick a character next time. It is very important to have an idea which characters will be picked before you’re up next. Let’s assume You want to trade goods for money: First, you need a plantation and a production plant, then you need to shuffle colonists on them, then produce goods tokens, at last – you are forced by a captain’s phase to convert the tokens into victory points (if you’re lucky and there’s a ship for them) instead of trading them in a trader’s phase. In Zen words: the shapeless form is the strongest. In my words: play so that the others are forced to help you while serving their own interest.
Experience tells: So far, our group of players finds the hospice, the hazienda, and the constructor’s hut to be the most rewarding support buildings. Try to get one or two of these right away. Get all three, and you’re unstoppable. Get none, and Your only hope is in a short game. As well, to have one of the storage buildings is regarded as indispensable by most of us (not me, though). Quarries are the best plantations, but it needs time until they make their weight felt.
Closer views:
The heavy strategy: You want to get four quarries asap, in order to construct a high-price, high-victory-point city. You must have a constructor’s hut, so you know what to do in the first builder phase. You will be short of plantations, colonists and money for a long time, so be careful if there’s a lot of production chains in the other player’s cities. These attract many colonists in the mayor phase, and the game may end so soon that You can’t harvest the returns of your investment. Best friends: hazienda, hospice.
The yellow strategy: You want to make use of the fact that corn fields need no factory in order to produce goods. In fact, you don’t need a single building, at all! Just make sure you get all corn that pops up in the settler phase and pick the captain yourself as often as you possibly can. You won’t have money – but you don’t need it, anyway! You will never have too few colonists. Ships at the quay, that’s what you need, and an early end to the game. Best friends: storehouse, wharf.
The scented strategy: Be the first to produce tobacco, later coffee. Trade like lightning and spend your income on buildings. Your problem is that you may be unable to trade sometimes, which can be a major setback. The good thing is that the money gives you flexibility. You will have to develop an idea how to make the best of the end game. Best friends: office, market.
The sweet strategy: You want to strike a balance between export and trade, between cash and victory points flow. Sugar is a very attractive commodity to produce in this case – the plantation is the second most abundant type, the trading price is reasonable, and the factories are not expensive to build. The problem is that you may end up a little short of money for that decisive building and with too little export for that extra victory point chip. Best friends: your keen sense for opportunities that open up. A short game probably doesn’t hurt.
The drugstore strategy: You want to produce as many different commodities as possible. It’s easier to implement than it sounds, and it avoids the pitfall of the trading business, i.e. not having the right commodity to sell. Beware of a short game, as it takes time to build the production chains. Obviously, the drugstore can develop out of the other strategies in the middle game. Best friends: harbour, factory.
Westpark Gamers‘ Rating: 8.17
Ein kleiner Regelfehler beim Aufbauen des Dungeons hatte nämlich fatale Folgen: dadurch daß jeder VOR dem Platzieren der Fallen und Monster seinen Eingang für das Team wählte (eigentlich NACHHER – meine Schuld!), waren diese Gänge dementsprechend von den anderen Spielern mit Hindernissen und Türen zugepflastert. Da immer nur eine Figur im Gang kämpfen konnte wurde die anderen 2 Aktivierungen für Monster verwendet, was natürlich zur Folge hatte, daß die Abenteurer der Reihe nach schon im Eintrittsgang abgeschlachtet wurden. Einzig und allein Hans’ und Walters Team konnte mittels eines Teleporters ins Zentrum des Dungeons vordringen, wo ihnen allerdings eine Schatztruhenfalle in Gestalt von 2 schier unbesiegbaren Minotauren den Garaus machte. Trotzdem hatten wir viel Spaß – die Qualität der Figuren und die Idee mit den drehbaren Figurenbasen kam gut an. Zumindest Peter wäre wohl auch weiterhin zu einem Spiel bereit (Walter wohl eher nicht 
)
Dieses Rennspiel, eine Art Robo Rally „light“ (die Hindernisse sind durch ein Pfeillabyrinth ersetzt, und man muß auch nur eine Bewegungskarte „planen“) benutzt die allseits beliebten Charaktere aus John Kovalic’s Comic „Dork Tower“ – es geht irgendwie darum, mit irgendwelchen Riesenhamstern irgendein skurriles Rennen zu gewinnen, also eigentlich ein abstraktes Spiel ohne irgendwelchen tieferen Themenbezug (die „special abilities“ der Charaktere erscheinen dementsprechend auch vollkommen willkürlich ausgewählt – mit dem Comic hat das nix zu tun). Das Spiel hinterlässt, genauso wie